Christmas Gift Crisis!?

My boyfriend and i have been dating for a little over 9 months.....I want to get him something really great. He plays baseball, runs cross county and does wrestling. He is really fit and into the Redskins and Braves. He shops at stores like Hollister and American Eagle. I just don't know. I want to something different. Other than the T-shirt gift. Something he will really like. Please help with ideas.......